MTB Tech Rumors and Innovation

Related:
metadave
Posts
1244
Joined
2/15/2016
Location
Revelstoke, BC CA
10/9/2023 9:50pm
Noeserd wrote:
But then why motorcycles doesn't suffer the same rigidity problems? It's not like they have massive axles or big contact points for example this is my...

But then why motorcycles doesn't suffer the same rigidity problems?

It's not like they have massive axles or big contact points

for example this is my bikes axle 

KTM RC390 axlesliders R1

 

Because a motorcycle fork doesn't have to be under 4 pounds for its intended audience. They can use thicker tubes, heavier materials and designs to make it stiffer without it being a market failure or affecting human powered performance. 

16
trexyz
Posts
115
Joined
10/18/2016
Location
RO
10/9/2023 11:21pm
Robstyle wrote:
I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅 It's wonderful...

I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅

It's wonderful in a straight line though, esp under braking. 

I also have a Dorado on my current bike, tbh I don’t feel any flex but I’m not a pro. What I like about USD forks is that you always get the same feeling, like when you service the lower…They might be a little bit heavier than regular forks but the small bump sensitivity is on top of everything. There are some teams that are running Dorado’s at world cups and they got some good results. Like someone said earlier, it’s all about money. Fox/Sram have deep pockets, Manitou on the other side are a small brand compared with these guys. Keep an eye on EXT they will release a new DH fork next year and they will support a big factory team (that’s what I heard from the regional EXT distributor), the new fork might be USD based on the current EXT Ferro.

5
10/10/2023 1:30am Edited Date/Time 10/10/2023 1:46am

Let’s just wait for the Push fork to be released and find out how they worked out rigidity.  

Kapolczer wrote:
Might not have to wait to much longer, this was posted today from Darren.

Might not have to wait to much longer, this was posted today from Darren.IMG 7109.jpeg?VersionId=B6IvvqRWmn01hA0og0xXcXdCt

What bugs me the most is that there’s no detailed info about this fork, like price, what axle, what spring, how much travel, what adjustments, different versions, a2c, offset, weight, some comparison for rigidity (even if not so detailed - it would be enough to say “we made sure it’s the same as 38/Zeb rigid-wise”). 

5
Ducki
Posts
8
Joined
11/22/2017
Location
DE
10/10/2023 1:52am
mtbboy1993 wrote:
https://www.facebook.com/birdmtb.co.uk/posts/pfbid02e7mJAqZ5PTVK1gJcfTuz8rQsAkKcyF4eNYLqe5quqq8pTE1jgjux7iQYXPzrCt2Ml Bird Cycleworks stops production of 27.5 bikes, so 27.5 models have a reduced price. https://www.bird.bike/aeris-am/ New bike release: Aeris AM 160mm Carbon

https://www.facebook.com/birdmtb.co.uk/posts/pfbid02e7mJAqZ5PTVK1gJcfTuz8rQsAkKcyF4eNYLqe5quqq8pTE1jgjux7iQYXPzrCt2Ml

Bird Cycleworks stops production of 27.5 bikes, so 27.5 models have a reduced price.

image-20231009210842-2

https://www.bird.bike/aeris-am/

New bike release:

Aeris AM 160mm Carbon

https://www.bird.bike/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Aeris-am-header-scaled.jpg

Mainframe looks exactly like an RM Altitude.

Primoz
Posts
4534
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/10/2023 7:17am Edited Date/Time 10/10/2023 10:43am

Considering a lot of the motorbike forks are shiny silver... Are the stanchions steel and chromed? Or do they use aluminium like on bikes?

1
nskerb
Posts
336
Joined
3/3/2020
Location
Kelso, WA US
10/10/2023 7:18am
Primoz wrote:

Considering a lot of the motorbike forks are shiny silver... Are the stanchions steel and chromed? Or do they use aluminium like on bikes?

Steel. 

5
10/10/2023 9:42am Edited Date/Time 10/10/2023 9:55am
Dave_Camp wrote:
I see 2 clamping bolts on each dropout that rs1 didn’t have. steel axle? Diameter?  Torsional stiffness is squared or cubed based off radius I think...

I see 2 clamping bolts on each dropout that rs1 didn’t have.

steel axle? Diameter?  Torsional stiffness is squared or cubed based off radius I think.  So even a small bump in diameter is big for torsion.

triple clamp? Stiffness of those?

lots of small differences make a big overall impact.

 

 

The flex near the axle is from bending moment, not torsion. It is comparatively easy to resist twisting of a material, as opposed to clamping a certain distance apart, and then resisting bending between those two points. 

In fact bending (from one point) is one the more famous / infamous mechanical engineering problems for students.

 

1
4
airwreck
Posts
105
Joined
4/7/2015
Location
Wailuku, HI US
10/10/2023 9:50am
Primoz wrote:

Considering a lot of the motorbike forks are shiny silver... Are the stanchions steel and chromed? Or do they use aluminium like on bikes?

Interesting how trials bikes aren't USD and it looks like a lot of them are Kashima.

Primoz
Posts
4534
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/10/2023 10:43am
Dave_Camp wrote:
I see 2 clamping bolts on each dropout that rs1 didn’t have. steel axle? Diameter?  Torsional stiffness is squared or cubed based off radius I think...

I see 2 clamping bolts on each dropout that rs1 didn’t have.

steel axle? Diameter?  Torsional stiffness is squared or cubed based off radius I think.  So even a small bump in diameter is big for torsion.

triple clamp? Stiffness of those?

lots of small differences make a big overall impact.

 

Tim Horton wrote:
  The flex near the axle is from bending moment, not torsion. It is comparatively easy to resist twisting of a material, as opposed to clamping...

 

The flex near the axle is from bending moment, not torsion. It is comparatively easy to resist twisting of a material, as opposed to clamping a certain distance apart, and then resisting bending between those two points. 

In fact bending (from one point) is one the more famous / infamous mechanical engineering problems for students.

 

Uuuuuum... No.

5
mitch_c4
Posts
2
Joined
2/20/2019
Location
AU
10/10/2023 5:02pm
Robstyle wrote:
I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅 It's wonderful...

I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅

It's wonderful in a straight line though, esp under braking. 

trexyz wrote:
I also have a Dorado on my current bike, tbh I don’t feel any flex but I’m not a pro. What I like about USD forks...

I also have a Dorado on my current bike, tbh I don’t feel any flex but I’m not a pro. What I like about USD forks is that you always get the same feeling, like when you service the lower…They might be a little bit heavier than regular forks but the small bump sensitivity is on top of everything. There are some teams that are running Dorado’s at world cups and they got some good results. Like someone said earlier, it’s all about money. Fox/Sram have deep pockets, Manitou on the other side are a small brand compared with these guys. Keep an eye on EXT they will release a new DH fork next year and they will support a big factory team (that’s what I heard from the regional EXT distributor), the new fork might be USD based on the current EXT Ferro.

Fox/rs would have their own reasons for not developing a usd fork (including tooling/development investment). Fox actually developed a usd dh fork at one point, pretty sure minarr and maybe gee were testing it? Apparently great in straight line, not so much in hard cornering and the weight increase required was beyond what they were willing to sell. I did my thesis on the torsional flex in usd forks, built a jig to actually get some data on them too. While it wasonly a static (not dynamic) test, it did allow me to work out that a large degree of torsional flex comes more from the constraints between the components (ie twisting between stanchion and outer). This is resolved on traditional forks coz the lowers constrain the two legs of the fork from both twisting and flexing fore/aft individually. This constraining is the same idea that the cdale lefty, x fusion revel and to a degree dvo’s cta utilise, and one I’ve worked on myself. As for the widespread use of usd forks on motos, the fore/aft loads are significantly higher, as the fork is bolted to the front of a much heavier bike that goes much faster and hits things harder. However, the torsional loading of forks on motos and mtbs are actually pretty close to the same - they are all reacted by the rider (with maybe some small input from steering dampeners). The fore/aft strength requirements for a moto (massive outers, massive steel stanchions, bigger axle, etc) and the fact they don’t have to pedal the fork around means that more as a byproduct of other load cases they have significantly increased torsional stiffness compared to mtb usd forks and thus they don’t notice it. I have a pair of the new dorados (with the alloy outers) and while I prefer them to boxers, they were very much complete noodles. Now, not so much, I’ve found a better balance of fore/aft and torsional flex to suit my riding style and conditions and reckon they feel miles better than other traditional forks I’ve ridden. I don’t believe USDs will become widespread due to their either increased weight or complication to increase torsional stiffness to a reasonable level where traditional forks can achieve this very easily but guess it depends on what riders are ok comprimksing on. I’m personally keen to see what push have come up with!

9
jsray
Posts
216
Joined
5/20/2017
Location
Gilbert, AZ US
10/10/2023 7:06pm

K. That’s enough of USD fork talk here. 

11
5
10/10/2023 9:22pm

Screenshot 20231010 222057 Instagram

Back side of the new 38mm Marzocchi fork

11
Primoz
Posts
4534
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/10/2023 9:50pm Edited Date/Time 10/10/2023 9:51pm
Robstyle wrote:
I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅 It's wonderful...

I have a dorado, she's a wet noodle torsionally alright. Sometimes the bars don't point where the wheel is out of a corner 😅

It's wonderful in a straight line though, esp under braking. 

trexyz wrote:
I also have a Dorado on my current bike, tbh I don’t feel any flex but I’m not a pro. What I like about USD forks...

I also have a Dorado on my current bike, tbh I don’t feel any flex but I’m not a pro. What I like about USD forks is that you always get the same feeling, like when you service the lower…They might be a little bit heavier than regular forks but the small bump sensitivity is on top of everything. There are some teams that are running Dorado’s at world cups and they got some good results. Like someone said earlier, it’s all about money. Fox/Sram have deep pockets, Manitou on the other side are a small brand compared with these guys. Keep an eye on EXT they will release a new DH fork next year and they will support a big factory team (that’s what I heard from the regional EXT distributor), the new fork might be USD based on the current EXT Ferro.

mitch_c4 wrote:
Fox/rs would have their own reasons for not developing a usd fork (including tooling/development investment). Fox actually developed a usd dh fork at one point, pretty...

Fox/rs would have their own reasons for not developing a usd fork (including tooling/development investment). Fox actually developed a usd dh fork at one point, pretty sure minarr and maybe gee were testing it? Apparently great in straight line, not so much in hard cornering and the weight increase required was beyond what they were willing to sell. I did my thesis on the torsional flex in usd forks, built a jig to actually get some data on them too. While it wasonly a static (not dynamic) test, it did allow me to work out that a large degree of torsional flex comes more from the constraints between the components (ie twisting between stanchion and outer). This is resolved on traditional forks coz the lowers constrain the two legs of the fork from both twisting and flexing fore/aft individually. This constraining is the same idea that the cdale lefty, x fusion revel and to a degree dvo’s cta utilise, and one I’ve worked on myself. As for the widespread use of usd forks on motos, the fore/aft loads are significantly higher, as the fork is bolted to the front of a much heavier bike that goes much faster and hits things harder. However, the torsional loading of forks on motos and mtbs are actually pretty close to the same - they are all reacted by the rider (with maybe some small input from steering dampeners). The fore/aft strength requirements for a moto (massive outers, massive steel stanchions, bigger axle, etc) and the fact they don’t have to pedal the fork around means that more as a byproduct of other load cases they have significantly increased torsional stiffness compared to mtb usd forks and thus they don’t notice it. I have a pair of the new dorados (with the alloy outers) and while I prefer them to boxers, they were very much complete noodles. Now, not so much, I’ve found a better balance of fore/aft and torsional flex to suit my riding style and conditions and reckon they feel miles better than other traditional forks I’ve ridden. I don’t believe USDs will become widespread due to their either increased weight or complication to increase torsional stiffness to a reasonable level where traditional forks can achieve this very easily but guess it depends on what riders are ok comprimksing on. I’m personally keen to see what push have come up with!

https://www.pinkbike.com/news/throwback-thursday-foxs-upside-down-proto…

Gee rode it in 2011 and based off the article, it was Gwin who gave it a shot. Pretty sure the Syndicate was still on Sram  kit back in 2011 when this proto was current.

Anywho as for USD vs. non-USD, i'll just leave this here again: https://www.vitalmtb.com/forums/The-Hub,2/How-stiff-are-dual-crown-fork…

6
mitch_c4
Posts
2
Joined
2/20/2019
Location
AU
10/10/2023 10:42pm
Primoz wrote:
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/throwback-thursday-foxs-upside-down-prototype-downhill-fork.html Gee rode it in 2011 and based off the article, it was Gwin who gave it a shot. Pretty sure the Syndicate was still on...

https://www.pinkbike.com/news/throwback-thursday-foxs-upside-down-proto…

Gee rode it in 2011 and based off the article, it was Gwin who gave it a shot. Pretty sure the Syndicate was still on Sram  kit back in 2011 when this proto was current.

Anywho as for USD vs. non-USD, i'll just leave this here again: https://www.vitalmtb.com/forums/The-Hub,2/How-stiff-are-dual-crown-fork…

Sorry mate saw usd forks and got a bit carried away there, back to the main subject. 

2
Robstyle
Posts
85
Joined
1/2/2023
Location
Invercargill NZ
10/10/2023 11:00pm
Primoz wrote:
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/throwback-thursday-foxs-upside-down-prototype-downhill-fork.html Gee rode it in 2011 and based off the article, it was Gwin who gave it a shot. Pretty sure the Syndicate was still on...

https://www.pinkbike.com/news/throwback-thursday-foxs-upside-down-proto…

Gee rode it in 2011 and based off the article, it was Gwin who gave it a shot. Pretty sure the Syndicate was still on Sram  kit back in 2011 when this proto was current.

Anywho as for USD vs. non-USD, i'll just leave this here again: https://www.vitalmtb.com/forums/The-Hub,2/How-stiff-are-dual-crown-fork…

mitch_c4 wrote:

Sorry mate saw usd forks and got a bit carried away there, back to the main subject. 

Ha, I believe a graph you came up with on the subject caused a stir with one passionate fellow. 

 

Sorry yes back on track now team... 

2
boozed
Posts
649
Joined
6/11/2019
Location
AU
10/11/2023 4:27am Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 4:35am

Huge discounts on Fox 38s here in Australia, better than half price in some cases.  Are they simply overstocked or is there a new 38 coming?

6
dolface
Posts
1662
Joined
10/26/2015
Location
CA US
10/11/2023 6:17am
boozed wrote:

Huge discounts on Fox 38s here in Australia, better than half price in some cases.  Are they simply overstocked or is there a new 38 coming?

Maybe the first to have the LMT damper (tho not sure if it's a damper or a tune...)?

2
fluider
Posts
37
Joined
1/7/2021
Location
SK
10/11/2023 6:30am

Or they're trying to get rid of them before the new MZ 38 lands as it'll surely be cheaper.

4
Jakub_G
Posts
352
Joined
8/7/2019
Location
SK
10/11/2023 7:36am
fluider wrote:

Or they're trying to get rid of them before the new MZ 38 lands as it'll surely be cheaper.

Not the same market, kashima vs non kashima...

2
4
MTBrent
Posts
104
Joined
7/7/2015
Location
Concord, NH US
10/11/2023 7:44am

IMG 1412.jpeg?VersionId=ZqZbi

10
pablo_b
Posts
32
Joined
11/6/2018
Location
CH
10/11/2023 7:46am

Most likely the proto DemoWhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (2)WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (1) wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

7
2
Primoz
Posts
4534
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/11/2023 8:02am

Edit your post, it got broken a bit, at first glance it looks like you're posting pictures of the current/old demo saying it's the proto one Smile

14
dolface
Posts
1662
Joined
10/26/2015
Location
CA US
10/11/2023 8:03am
pablo_b wrote:
Most likely the proto Demo wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

Most likely the proto DemoWhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (2)WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (1) wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

Looks like that NASA wheel tech has arrived! Wink

 

(No valve stems)

7
Losifer
Posts
407
Joined
9/12/2017
Location
Sandia Park, NM US
10/11/2023 8:59am Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 9:22am

I know someone mentioned that the Manitou Mezzer might get updated. Well, it's on sale for $660 on the Hayes site right now with low quantities, so I think that rumor might get verified soon.

3
10/11/2023 9:23am
pablo_b wrote:
Most likely the proto Demo wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

Most likely the proto DemoWhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (2)WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (1) wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

dolface wrote:

Looks like that NASA wheel tech has arrived! Wink

 

(No valve stems)

The technology needed to digitally render valve stems is still decades away.

19
jonkranked
Posts
1182
Joined
5/5/2016
Location
Norristown, PA US
10/11/2023 12:39pm
pablo_b wrote:
Most likely the proto Demo wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

Most likely the proto DemoWhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (2)WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02WhatsApp Image 2023-09-27 at 13.22.02 (1) wont be released until 2025. 2024 colorways "leaked"

dolface wrote:

Looks like that NASA wheel tech has arrived! Wink

 

(No valve stems)

The technology needed to digitally render valve stems is still decades away.

they're just having AI do the renderings now. at least the wheels are round.

3
brash
Posts
942
Joined
4/24/2019
Location
AU
10/11/2023 1:25pm
boozed wrote:

Huge discounts on Fox 38s here in Australia, better than half price in some cases.  Are they simply overstocked or is there a new 38 coming?

yep, $999.... I don't even need one but that's an insane price.

I actually asked the same question, massive overstock is the response I got. Nothing new coming.

2
peecee
Posts
425
Joined
5/12/2013
Location
Brisbane AU
10/11/2023 1:42pm Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 1:42pm

Everyone on here having a moan about USD forks not having any torsional stiffness, mean while Cannondale are like "Hold My Beer"  and have been doing for like 25 years 

 

Screenshot 2023-10-12 at 6.37.44 am.jpg?VersionId=H.Z8WzO

3
Primoz
Posts
4534
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/11/2023 1:51pm Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 1:52pm

Because the Lefty has three (used to be four) flat surfaces with needle bearings between them inside the housing. Which prevent rotation of the stanchion. Which is not the case with dual legged upside down forks.

USD forks are flexy because they don't have the bridge connecting the lowers that standard bike forks have. Take a standard MTB fork, cut away the bridge and it will be a noodle.

Back to rumors.

8
Post a reply to: MTB Tech Rumors and Innovation

This forum thread has been locked.

The Latest