MTB Tech Rumors and Innovation

Related:
gibbon
Posts
467
Joined
3/7/2019
Location
wales, GB
10/1/2024 3:23am Edited Date/Time 10/1/2024 3:25am
Nico_Hrndz wrote:

This might be the most unexciting bike I've seen in ages

2024-09-30-145645 trek--les-nouveaux-rail-powerfly-et-powerfly-fs%5Bb7e8120a6b8ac5d0ec2ea7343de8bf58172770127762%5D.jpg?VersionId=EKwpbjaVdY18I1F zFn1aQ6dago
22
gibbon
Posts
467
Joined
3/7/2019
Location
wales, GB
10/1/2024 3:30am

Bought by people who want tyres that are really knobbly and fast on road.And have 'gel' saddle covers.

8
axouloulou
Posts
1
Joined
10/1/2024
Location
Berlin, DE
10/1/2024 4:00am Edited Date/Time 10/1/2024 5:14am

Does someone know which fork was Dario Lilio riding this weekend in Lake Placid?
Black fox, i presume a 34 - with a new arch design.

5
29
Posts
235
Joined
3/9/2020
Location
AT
10/1/2024 5:38am

Why does the Rail+ look like something old people would ride on the bike path next to a river on a sunny weekend day


also can we please call Horst link bikes „crab link“ from now on it is fantastic

28
10/1/2024 6:01am

Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to differentiate the Vala from their other bikes. 

3
2supple
Posts
155
Joined
1/23/2022
Location
Denver, CO, USA
10/1/2024 6:16am
Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to...

Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to differentiate the Vala from their other bikes. 

Not pedantic but easily explained with a quick google search. Easiest thing to distinguish 4bar/horst link is the pivot near the rear axle. Their new ebike has it, all the VPP bikes do not. 

4
dolface
Posts
1714
Joined
10/26/2015
Location
USA
10/1/2024 6:22am
honeymoon wrote:
Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new...

Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new gravel frame of theirs?  

https://opencycle.com/blog/new-direction-for-up-and-upper

Screenshot 2024-10-01 at 8.06.50%E2%80%AFPM.png?VersionId=YBlNtnG

Oh good, ANOTHER "standard"... 🙄

2
3
Primoz
Posts
4677
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/1/2024 6:28am
Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to...

Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to differentiate the Vala from their other bikes. 

It is. 

5
Primoz
Posts
4677
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
10/1/2024 6:30am
Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to...

Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to differentiate the Vala from their other bikes. 

2supple wrote:
Not pedantic but easily explained with a quick google search. Easiest thing to distinguish 4bar/horst link is the pivot near the rear axle. Their new ebike...

Not pedantic but easily explained with a quick google search. Easiest thing to distinguish 4bar/horst link is the pivot near the rear axle. Their new ebike has it, all the VPP bikes do not. 

Horst link is one of the variants of a 4 bar design. 

12
chriskief
Posts
793
Joined
4/15/2017
Location
New York, NY, USA
Fantasy
10/1/2024 6:30am
honeymoon wrote:
Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new...

Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new gravel frame of theirs?  

https://opencycle.com/blog/new-direction-for-up-and-upper

Screenshot 2024-10-01 at 8.06.50%E2%80%AFPM.png?VersionId=YBlNtnG

dolface wrote:

Oh good, ANOTHER "standard"... 🙄

The first bullet says it’s a UDH frame, so whatever Shimano is doing is compatible with that standard.

10
2supple
Posts
155
Joined
1/23/2022
Location
Denver, CO, USA
10/1/2024 6:35am
Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to...

Apologies if this is pedantic or already discussed. Is VPP not also a 4 bar suspension design? Confused why Santa Cruz is using that terminology to differentiate the Vala from their other bikes. 

2supple wrote:
Not pedantic but easily explained with a quick google search. Easiest thing to distinguish 4bar/horst link is the pivot near the rear axle. Their new ebike...

Not pedantic but easily explained with a quick google search. Easiest thing to distinguish 4bar/horst link is the pivot near the rear axle. Their new ebike has it, all the VPP bikes do not. 

Primoz wrote:

Horst link is one of the variants of a 4 bar design. 

Good job, and the ebike in question is a horst link 

1
Eoin
Posts
393
Joined
3/6/2015
Location
FR
Fantasy
10/1/2024 6:51am

None of these bosch bikes are that exciting to me right now, the Vala being in direct competition with the Rise LT and AMflow is kinda nuts considering how poorly it compares on paper (obviously SC will have a major win in build quality and customer service). 

The crestline S180 is dreamy, but well outside of my budget, I have put 2-3 frames in the landfill over the last 10 years, so a 10k bike seems like a bad idea.

French brand moustache will announce their concept this week, look like they rotated the motor and slid the battery almost below the motor, similar idea to the lapierre GLP aiming to centralise the weight as much as possible. Orbea are rumoured to release a 170/170 wild, but unclear which battery it will fit.

Also isn't this the second time Bosch have announed their motor and partner frames, but then refused to show the frame mounted display, I find this 100% insane, just show us a render or a plastic mockup if you don't have it ready, why hide it? It's going to be small screen with power mode and battery level, what exactly do you think we are missing here?

If only the AMflow was a 160+ rear travel bike with a non-trunnion shock the decision would be so easy! 

6
1
gibbon
Posts
467
Joined
3/7/2019
Location
wales, GB
10/1/2024 6:54am
honeymoon wrote:
Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new...

Not sure if this was caught by anyone else, but Open might have just leaked some details on a new Shimano derailleur while promoting a new gravel frame of theirs?  

https://opencycle.com/blog/new-direction-for-up-and-upper

Screenshot 2024-10-01 at 8.06.50%E2%80%AFPM.png?VersionId=YBlNtnG

dolface wrote:

Oh good, ANOTHER "standard"... 🙄

chriskief wrote:

The first bullet says it’s a UDH frame, so whatever Shimano is doing is compatible with that standard.

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

21
chriskief
Posts
793
Joined
4/15/2017
Location
New York, NY, USA
Fantasy
10/1/2024 7:02am
dolface wrote:

Oh good, ANOTHER "standard"... 🙄

chriskief wrote:

The first bullet says it’s a UDH frame, so whatever Shimano is doing is compatible with that standard.

gibbon wrote:

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

If the frame is UDH and also compatible with new Shimano derailleur, likely the frame standard is the same and the Shimano mount bolt (T-Type for SRAM) will be different.

4
10/1/2024 7:11am
Rick26 wrote:
2025 Rail is up on Trek EU websites with all builds & prices, but the bike is still not released or shown anywhere else (no US/CAN...

2025 Rail is up on Trek EU websites with all builds & prices, but the bike is still not released or shown anywhere else (no US/CAN prices/builds or review out).

https://www.trekbikes.com/gb/en_GB/rail-plus-high-powered-emtb/

Wowzers, 490/495 mm reach in a large and 450/455 for a medium, maybe some people will love that but that feels like to large of a...

Wowzers, 490/495 mm reach in a large and 450/455 for a medium, maybe some people will love that but that feels like to large of a jump between sizes,.

This has to be a typo right? Aren't most people on size L (M on some brans now) which is 470-480 reach??

5
10/1/2024 7:20am
Scontoni wrote:
More of the new Rail+
dfg564654dfg4g11g1dfg564654dfg4g11g2

More of the new Rail+

Nico_Hrndz wrote:

This might be the most unexciting bike I've seen in ages

Removable battery at least! Idk if I'd ever own a Trek other than my old Trek 8000 SL but I really like how they've stayed committed to removable batteries. I didn't even realize the Fuel Ex-E had a removable battery until recently, which makes total sense for a tiny 360wh unit.

I'd argue the Vala is slightly more unexciting.

1
1
Eoin
Posts
393
Joined
3/6/2015
Location
FR
Fantasy
10/1/2024 7:51am

This has to be a typo right? Aren't most people on size L (M on some brans now) which is 470-480 reach??

It makes no sense, especially as S->M is +2cm, M->L is +4cm, but L to XL is 2.5cm.

The only question mark is their headset cups, they could allow reach adjust, they only briefly mention them adjusting head angle.

1
10/1/2024 7:52am
gibbon wrote:

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

Hate to post a link to the other site, but its the only reference I could find - could well be Shimano's own direct mount... 

 

https://www.pinkbike.com/news/shimano-patent-shows-direct-mount-electro…

4
JVP
Posts
233
Joined
4/20/2016
Location
Bellingham, WA, USA
10/1/2024 7:53am
gibbon wrote:

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

Not quite an open standard. SRAM will grant you a license, at no cost, if you apply (I've done it). But it isn't open, and there's nothing saying they have to grant said license. When you apply, you interface with the SRAM legal team. I wouldn't be surprised if they're doing everything they can to make things challenging for Shimano, it's what big brands do to each other.

2
chriskief
Posts
793
Joined
4/15/2017
Location
New York, NY, USA
Fantasy
10/1/2024 8:37am
gibbon wrote:

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

JVP wrote:
Not quite an open standard. SRAM will grant you a license, at no cost, if you apply (I've done it). But it isn't open, and there's...

Not quite an open standard. SRAM will grant you a license, at no cost, if you apply (I've done it). But it isn't open, and there's nothing saying they have to grant said license. When you apply, you interface with the SRAM legal team. I wouldn't be surprised if they're doing everything they can to make things challenging for Shimano, it's what big brands do to each other.

Isn’t the license for the frame manufacturer? Assuming that’s the case, anyone can build a derailleur to mount to those frame specs. Or am I missing something?

2
bikelurker
Posts
183
Joined
3/23/2023
Location
Bilbao, Vizcaya, ES
10/1/2024 8:49am

FFS, it's just a hole! 

17
10/1/2024 9:37am
FaahkEet wrote:

So kind of like the biological world where everything becomes a crab.

nskerb wrote:

Yeah crabs are basically the horst link bikes of the animal world. Everything eventually evolves to crab. 

see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carcinisation

One of my favorite comments in a while 😂 Horst link = crab

Also, @cantstop you best be getting that crab-link trademark buttoned up... 

8
HexonJuan
Posts
407
Joined
6/10/2015
Location
USA
10/1/2024 10:08am
gibbon wrote:

Given UDH is an open standard and becoming industry wide it would make sense for Shimano to utilize it............so of course they won't do it.

JVP wrote:
Not quite an open standard. SRAM will grant you a license, at no cost, if you apply (I've done it). But it isn't open, and there's...

Not quite an open standard. SRAM will grant you a license, at no cost, if you apply (I've done it). But it isn't open, and there's nothing saying they have to grant said license. When you apply, you interface with the SRAM legal team. I wouldn't be surprised if they're doing everything they can to make things challenging for Shimano, it's what big brands do to each other.

Yeppers, same as when ISIS was a thing. I'll wager there's probably a bit of IP swapping happening in the background as well since SRAM were particular in their patent for their derailleurs. 

1
Rick26
Posts
75
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
., BC, CA
10/1/2024 10:08am Edited Date/Time 10/1/2024 10:09am
Rick26 wrote:
2025 Rail is up on Trek EU websites with all builds & prices, but the bike is still not released or shown anywhere else (no US/CAN...

2025 Rail is up on Trek EU websites with all builds & prices, but the bike is still not released or shown anywhere else (no US/CAN prices/builds or review out).

https://www.trekbikes.com/gb/en_GB/rail-plus-high-powered-emtb/

Wowzers, 490/495 mm reach in a large and 450/455 for a medium, maybe some people will love that but that feels like to large of a...

Wowzers, 490/495 mm reach in a large and 450/455 for a medium, maybe some people will love that but that feels like to large of a jump between sizes,.

This has to be a typo right? Aren't most people on size L (M on some brans now) which is 470-480 reach??

It's not the first time the Rail is getting some negative feedback for weird sizing/geo.

The L is more XL and their XL is XXL so you're right that they're not offering any size large...not sure how they can mess that up in 2024. 

Santa Cruz Vala sizing is much better as a reference.

Anyway, what kind of product launch is this from Trek ? Bike kind of soft launched in Europe only.

3
lickmycrinkle
Posts
228
Joined
1/27/2021
Location
Beverly Hills, CA, USA
10/1/2024 10:19am
29 wrote:
Why does the Rail+ look like something old people would ride on the bike path next to a river on a sunny weekend dayalso can we...

Why does the Rail+ look like something old people would ride on the bike path next to a river on a sunny weekend day


also can we please call Horst link bikes „crab link“ from now on it is fantastic

Sounds like you work in a Trek dealer.

It looks like it, because it is. It's a comfort tourer for oldies that equate suspension to comfort. They get loaded up with kickstands (in the provided mounting holes), mirrors, smartphone holders and Ergon wing grips.

They ride like a pig and have done since gen1.

8
grinch
Posts
271
Joined
10/15/2013
Location
CA
10/1/2024 10:43am
bikelurker wrote:

FFS, it's just a hole! 

This could be the start of a new thread....

13
Trocko
Posts
193
Joined
11/23/2010
Location
Rocky, CO, USA
10/1/2024 12:43pm

New Orbea ebike

IMG 4170 0
5
Evil96
Posts
875
Joined
8/21/2014
Location
Portogruaro, VE, IT
10/1/2024 12:44pm
29 wrote:
Why does the Rail+ look like something old people would ride on the bike path next to a river on a sunny weekend dayalso can we...

Why does the Rail+ look like something old people would ride on the bike path next to a river on a sunny weekend day


also can we please call Horst link bikes „crab link“ from now on it is fantastic

Sounds like you work in a Trek dealer.It looks like it, because it is. It's a comfort tourer for oldies that equate suspension to comfort. They...

Sounds like you work in a Trek dealer.

It looks like it, because it is. It's a comfort tourer for oldies that equate suspension to comfort. They get loaded up with kickstands (in the provided mounting holes), mirrors, smartphone holders and Ergon wing grips.

They ride like a pig and have done since gen1.

How come when I say this I get shit 😂 well said tho 

2
User83001
Posts
14
Joined
1/10/2023
Location
jackson, WY, USA
10/1/2024 1:19pm

new kona hei hei mid 2025

910DDCA6-B92A-4E86-BFAE-E39A3ABC450B 4 5005 c
6
Post a reply to: MTB Tech Rumors and Innovation

This forum thread has been locked.

The Latest