Just my 2 cents, a coil shock on a true trail/all-mountain bike isn't worth the price of admission, weight. I was riding my stumpy evo with a custom tuned coil, ate chunk for dinner, I said to myself, lets add a Smashpot, and a Lift... Next thing you know my carbon wheeled carbon frame all mountain bike weighed 39ish'lbs but was never really spectacular anywhere. Bought a Madonna and slowly converted the stumpy back to its roots and It was the best decision ever. Its back to weighing >35lbs, pops off of everything, and is a blast to ride, on...