Nicolai G1 2025 – got a different top tube than they show on the website 😑 help pls.

rely
Posts
3
Joined
11/2/2025
Location
Bratislava - Nové Mesto, SK
Edited Date/Time 4 hours ago

Hi guys,

I ordered a G1-275 frame (size  directly from Nicolai's e-shop in September 2025. I've been riding it for about a year with a Fox 40 dual crown. Some time ago I noticed dents on the top tube, both of them from the Fox 40 stanchions. No crash, nothing like that. So I contacted Nicolai to ask if they can help me with it somehow.

While I was dealing with this, I noticed that my top tube is completely different from what Nicolai shows on their website. Check the photos:

1) My frame – big oval top tube that gets much thicker towards the seat tube.
2) Nicolai website, G1 product page – slim square top tube, same thickness along the whole length.
3) G1 size M from a YouTube video (March 2025) – the same square top tube as on the website.

Nicolai told me it's an improved version. But as far as I found out, it's the top tube they use on their e-bikes. And their website still shows the square one, so honestly I don't understand why mine should be the "better" version when they still present the other one.

I paid for the bike they presented, and I got something different, without any information before delivery. I don't think that's OK.

And what do you think about this? Is it normal that a manufacturer changes the design like this without telling the customer, while the website still shows the old one? I'd really like to hear your opinion.G1 porovnanie hornej ruri v2 1

|
3 hours ago

It is an improved version. The old versions all went to help starving children in Africa.

3
Big Bird
Posts
2368
Joined
2/1/2011
Location
Oceano, CA, USA
3 hours ago

One year at Sea Otter they showed up with a brand new frame design. I test rode it and it was hot garbage. It was as if it was Designed for maximum pedal bob. When I brought it back the guy was talking to a woman and asked me how I liked it. I told him it was the worst riding bike that I'd ever ridden. I've never been looked at with so much hatred. I assume that yours rides a bit better. As for your frame, I'm not at all surprised. They most likely ran out of the tube in the catalog and just used something else. They'll probably tell you that the frame was not meant to be ridden with a 40 and deny you a new frame. 

1
metadave
Posts
1300
Joined
2/15/2016
Location
Revelstoke, BC, CA
Fantasy
3 hours ago
Tim Horton wrote:

It is an improved version. The old versions all went to help starving children in Africa.

#toptubesforafrica is my favorite charity. 

Small custom build made to order brand running out of the exact tube in a photo during an aluminum shortage isn't a huge surprise, but I'd at least expect them to let you know there was a change. 

That being said, they also might make changes on the fly without updating their photos. Large brands do it all the time with spec and I've seen running changes in other places when they found an issue. Maybe they found there were cracking issues with the previous tube so swapped to something else. It does say one the G1 page it's duel crown compatible. 

From.your description, it says they have admitted to having a different tube, have they replied regarding the dents?

rely
Posts
3
Joined
11/2/2025
Location
Bratislava - Nové Mesto, SK
3 hours ago

@metadave  â€“ good point about the dual crown, the G1 page really says it's dual crown compatible, that's why I ran the Fox 40 on it. About the dents, Nicolai refused to replace the frame and also refused any discount.

Their answer about the top tube was that they changed it to make the bike as good as possible 😄 OK, but then why does their website still show the square tube? And why did other G1s from the same time get the square tube? If the new one is the better version, I'd expect them to show it, or at least tell the customer before delivery. I paid for the bike they presented, nobody told me anything.


 

rely
Posts
3
Joined
11/2/2025
Location
Bratislava - Nové Mesto, SK
3 hours ago

@Big Bird  â€“ yeah, that's pretty much how I see it too 🙄


 

Fred_Pop
Posts
268
Joined
11/26/2017
Location
FR
1 hour ago

I've had the older version from 2020 with a round top tube. Have run a Dorado on it always. After 6 years I only have one small crack on the weld on one of the shock mounts. I have heard of a local bikepark rat that has broken numerous Nicolai frames. Have always had good service from Nicolai and Geometron myself. Try talking to the Geometron guys, maybe they have different feedback.
 

Stewyeww
Posts
257
Joined
6/10/2021
Location
CA
1 hour ago

Well it took you over a year to notice sooooo...................

1
46 minutes ago
Stewyeww wrote:

Well it took you over a year to notice sooooo...................

Yeah, I'm with you. The time to rise this with Nicolai would've been at delivery of the (unridden) frame. 

metadave
Posts
1300
Joined
2/15/2016
Location
Revelstoke, BC, CA
Fantasy
5 minutes ago
rely wrote:
@metadave  â€“ good point about the dual crown, the G1 page really says it's dual crown compatible, that's why I ran the Fox 40 on it...

@metadave  â€“ good point about the dual crown, the G1 page really says it's dual crown compatible, that's why I ran the Fox 40 on it. About the dents, Nicolai refused to replace the frame and also refused any discount.

Their answer about the top tube was that they changed it to make the bike as good as possible 😄 OK, but then why does their website still show the square tube? And why did other G1s from the same time get the square tube? If the new one is the better version, I'd expect them to show it, or at least tell the customer before delivery. I paid for the bike they presented, nobody told me anything.


 

Yeah the dents are frustrating. If it's going to be dial crown compatible they should at least give you some support. 

As for the website, a lot of small and mod size bike companies are extraordinary smaller than you think they are staff wise. Rocky mountain for example before "the situation" only had about 30-35 staff. Banshee only has 4-5 from what I remember. I think I tense had 15. I'm not sure what Nicolai has, but I'm sure it's small enough that dedication of one of their staffs time to take photos of a small running change to a frame would take away from things that keep the lights on.and it's likely constantly pushed back on the priority list by other things, if it's even on it. I know it's frustrating in this case, but it's the reality of running a business some times

The bike industry shouldn't even exist the way it is with the thin margins and way things work, but passionate people enjoy low wages to bring you product that they love. it's basically the restaurant industry but a pizza is $8000 and gets driven home thrown into the back of the pick up truck without a box. In this case you got mushrooms by accident. 

Post a reply to: Nicolai G1 2025 – got a different top tube than they show on the website 😑 help pls.

The Latest