Vital Flat Pedal Face Off: Crowd Source Edition

Related:
AndehM
Posts
919
Joined
5/7/2018
Location
El Granada, CA, USA
Fantasy
Edited Date/Time 1 day ago

I'm a big fan of the ongoing Vital MTB Face Off: The Best Flat Pedals, but there's always a few pedals I'm curious about that aren't tested.  And I've also gotten burned by a few pedals that rank well on the list which turn out to have mediocre durability.  I think it'd be cool if we could crowd source some additions to the list, and list experience with long term durability (~1 year of use in heavy rotation).  The grip score is subjective but I think all the rest could be done easily.

I just picked up a set of Wolf Tooth Wave Performance pedals, and hope to get some of the relevant stats on them.  One ride on them and I have a few thoughts.  The left pedal was very sticky out of the box, which persisted through the ride.  After riding, I disassembled and reassembled, and was able to get it to feel similar to the right.  It felt like something was installed incorrectly at the factory (either the rubber seal or the bearings) and was binding.  The Q-factor is extremely narrow, sitting close to the cranks, which I suspect will cause issues with my Impact Pros (first ride was with Freerider Pros).  The stock steel pins came from the factory without Loctite applied.  4 spare pins were included in the box.  Their stated concavity seems exaggerated (need to complete measurements):  the leading edge is 16mm tall, but the bulge at the axle is 18.3mm tall.

  • effective concavity: 6mm
  • PTA:  105mm
  • Weight:  384g claimed, 385 actual
  • Thickness at Thickest:  18mm
  • Thickness w/ Pins:  25mm

Other pedals I've spent a lot of time on in the last 2 years:

2026 Race Face Turbines.  They are very grippy, as advertised.  The platform is nice and large, and doesn't sit too close to the cranks (useful when using large soled shoes such as Impact Pros).  While having a profiled front edge, they are taller than other pedals I've used, and show more scars from hitting rocks and stumps.  The stock pins are the same length as others I have in my spares box, but are slightly more recessed into the body giving a slightly taller effective height than usual.  The silver color's finish is more shiny than most other silver anodized parts, which makes the match a little less ideal.  I have 2 sets of them, and they all had varying amounts of free spin out of the box, which has persisted after opening them up to clean and regrease, which suggests a tolerance issue.  I've also run into a perplexing issue on one of my bikes where both sets of pedals develops a clicking sound after about 1,000' of pedaling, which disappears if I remove and reinstall the pedals.  This doesn't happen on my other bike.  I need to see if adding a pedal washer helps the clicking (I don't understand why it would, but it's an easy try).  Internals looked clean when I checked after 6 months of use with no lateral play.

2025 Deity Supervillains.  Very familiar feel to the legendary T-Macs, with just a tiny bit more grip.  I owned 3 pairs of the Supervillain at one point across my bikes.  However, after about a year, the 2 pairs in heavy use developed lateral play.  I took them apart and found uneven wear (one side only) on the spindles where the bushings rub.  Upon regrease and reassembly, one of the 2 sets had the play go away.  The other set's play persisted, and I sent them in to Deity where they replaced the internals under warranty.  The silver anodizing had a beautiful satin finish and was an excellent match for other products (like Industry Nine or Chris King).  I ended up selling 2 sets and am keeping the least used pair as a backup.  My biggest complaints with this pedal was a lack of rear loading to allow for pins instead of grub screws, and sealing/durability.

1
|
Suns_PSD
Posts
418
Joined
10/7/2015
Location
Austin, TX, USA
1 day ago Edited Date/Time 1 day ago

The Newman Beskar's are the best pedals I've ever had, by a pretty large margin. So durable, can remove the pins from the same side in case they get bent, except smashing them constantly and they still are 100% fine 2+ years later. They also look great, feel great & and are oddly light (like really light).

 

Being able to remove the pins from the same side using even pliers or a wrench (not an Allen wrench) was the primary thing I was looking for which is why I choose the Beskar's, but like I said, I can't hurt these pins or the pedals and let me tell you, I really try. 

 

If they give up on me, I will simply order another set right away at whatever cost.

 

The worst pedals I've ever had are the Oneup Composites. Completely needed a rebuild within weeks, every pin smashed beyond recognition and very difficult to remove bent pins in a composite pedal. Rebuilt them at some cost as I had to order new pins and it took a couple of hours, went in the trash just weeks later when they were yet again completely unusable. I don't really blame Oneup for this and I'm sure they are fine for people that don't ride any rocks, like at all.

 

I've had lots of other pedals in there and most all are about the same really. I still have a set of Magnesium Crampons that I bought 10+ years ago and they still run on my gf's bike bike but the pins are too hammered for what I'd want. Having the convex shape does make them feel slightly weird though.

1
AndehM
Posts
919
Joined
5/7/2018
Location
El Granada, CA, USA
Fantasy
22 hours ago

I returned the Wolf Tooth Wave Performance pedals, and picked up a set of Tenet Occult v3s.  I've previously owned the Occult v1 and found it grippy but the sealing a bit lacking.  The v3 has a new sealing design, revised shape (even more concavity), and now is offered in silver instead of pewter (yay!).  I've only had a few rides on the Occult v3, but have been impressed so far, putting the grip as good or better than the Turbines, and better than Supervillains.  I swapped out the pins for the included grub screws from the start, as I've found that grubs work better with soft Stealth rubber (and chew up the soles less).  Only gripe so far is the right pedal spins more freely than the left, which likely means it needs a bit more grease inside.  These will be a great value if the new labyrinth seals hold up, at only $130/set.  I did take measurements to see how they compare to the Occult v2 that Johan tested.

  • effective concavity: 9mm
  • PTA:  109mm
  • Weight:  460g claimed, 418g actual (with pins not grubs)
  • Thickness at Thickest:  17mm
  • Thickness w/ Pins:  31mm

Side note:  anyone know of a replacement standard diameter threaded pin-style (with bolt head) like Praxis uses?  As mentioned above, I prefer grub screws to round pins, but for rear loading pedals it's nice to have the bolt head to easily set the pins all at the same height.  Praxis grub-pins are perfect IMO, but very expensive ($15/12 pins) compared to sets of grubs (Burgtec is like $12/32 pins).  Looking for standard ~6.5mm exposed height.  Dagga pins are narrower and longer.  HT's AE01 maybe?

2
MistaMike
Posts
4
Joined
10/24/2024
Location
Pleasant Hill, CA, USA
2 hours ago

Great thread idea @AndehM I have some PNW Range composites on a DJ that have seen the least amount of use but have just enough grip but release easily.  I went through 2 sets of Vaults before trying some Daggas and most recently the newer Turbines.  The Vaults while grippy and strong, needed rebuilds more often than I expected.  The Daggas are bombproof, took a rock strike hard enough to send me out of the saddle and shrugged it off like it was nothing.  It seems like parts/tools are hard to come by for these though.  Otherwise the build quality and finish is top notch. I only tried the Turbines because I wanted a thick pedal option to slam a longer dropper into a frame.  They don't have the same burly feel or next level build quality as the Daggas but are holding up well.  The internals look good after a season of use, grease is clean and bearings spin freely.  I haven't had to tighten pins on either of these either.  I'd love to try some B-rage pedals next.

2
JVP
Posts
258
Joined
4/20/2016
Location
Bellingham, WA, USA
37 minutes ago

Currently on Chromag Scarabs and loving them. Correction, I never even think about them. The right balance of grip and being able to reposition, for me. Gotta run the pins in the longer setting by ditching the spacer-washers they come with. And don't put too many pins in, they run best with a "normal" number of pins. I initially tried 4 along the front, but 3 is better. I chose them for having good quality axles with replacements actually in stock - I have a long history of bending left/back pedal axles.

DMR Vaults are the least reliable pedal I've ever had the displeasure of using. Axles bent like warm butter and they got sloppy within a couple weeks. Replacement bushings were unobtanium in the USA.

Second worst is anything composite, specifically the OneUp. But none of them will last since pins rip out and bust up the plastic. The bike version of e-waste.

2

Post a reply to: Vital Flat Pedal Face Off: Crowd Source Edition

The Latest