Suspension Component Technology/Functionality Discussion

TEAMROBOT
Posts
1690
Joined
9/2/2009
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
Fantasy
8 hours ago Edited Date/Time 15 minutes ago
Primoz wrote:
There is no reason for the bushings to be further apart in a single crown fork, inverted or not. It can be a thing with dual...

There is no reason for the bushings to be further apart in a single crown fork, inverted or not. It can be a thing with dual crown inverted forks as the stanchions can travel past lower crown, can thus be longer for a given travel and the bushings can be further apart.

In a classic fork you can extend the lowers past the axle and get additional bushing separation that way. 

As for inverted fork benefits, the benefit is that the lower bushing at least and the seals are sitting in a bath of oil and thus should be smoother than in a conventional fork where these parts are not as well lubricated. 

Ooh. Yeah. Um... I'm going to have to go ahead and sort of disagree with you there. - Lumbergh ...

Hey @Primoz, sorry but I have to disagree with you on this one. The layout of an inverted single crown fork allows it to have significantly more bushing overlap than a comparable travel RSU fork. This was a frequent talking point at the Fox Podium camp I attended, and while it wasn't initially intuitive for me to understand, it finally clicked when I got out a measuring tape and looked at two comparable travel forks. In short, it all comes down to where the stanchions end up on a fork chassis because the stanchion location forces the designer's hand when it comes to bushing placement.

I've included two badly drawn pictures below that show why that's true, using my 2025 Fox 36 Float and 2026 Podium. I don't know the exact bushing overlap of the 36, and I suspect it's probably a little less than the 38, but the 36 is still capable of being run at 170mm like the Podium or 38, and the pictures do a good job of showing the inherent limitations of a single crown RSU layout if you want to maximize bushing overlap. I apologize in advance for my horrific lack of photoshop-y skills.

TLDR: the stanchion position, arch, and crown on the RSU fork are the things standing in the way of more bushing overlap:

Fox 36 vs Podium bushing overlap2.JPG?VersionId=s1x4.qGGqcYLmhu
More room for bushing overlap.

 

Fox 36 vs Podium bushing overlap 0
Less room for bushing overlap

Why 174mm in my photos? Because according to Fox, the Podium has 174.4mm of bushing overlap compared to 120mm for the 38. That’s a lot more, and according to Fox it's about the same amount as the 40 DH fork.

As you mentioned in your post, one way to get around this limitation on RSU forks is to move the bottom of the fork lowers further down, which allows the stanchion to travel further down at full bottom out. Like you said, "In a classic fork you can extend the lowers past the axle and get additional bushing separation that way":

Liquidación - Componentes - Fox 36 Float 26 180 RC2, FIT - Comprar en Bicimarket.com
By stretching the bottom of the fork lowers further down past the axle, you can sneak a longer overall stanchion length into the fork lowers and thereby create more overlap between the upper and lower bushings. 

The obvious downside of this design is that your fragile magnesium casting is now in harm's way for rock strikes and other accidents. It's what Fox did on the old long travel 26" 180mm 36 forks, and what Manitou did on the long travel 26" Travis single crown. Probably a few other examples I didn't remember, too:

I suspect fork manufacturers did this on the old 26" forks because there was so little room to work with inside the shorter lowers of a 26" fork, and they moved away from this design when front wheels got bigger and fork lowers were able to be stretched out, meaning they were able to accommodate more stanchion and bushing overlap inside the lowers without having the fragile magnesium fork lower hanging down below the axle.

The bushing overlap problem gets a lot easier to solve on a dual crown RSU fork because the crown can be so much lower profile. On a dual crown fork, the lower crown doesn't have to clear a bike's down tube when you turn the bars, so the lower crown doesn't have to project as far down from the steerer tube as it would on a single crown. This allows you to move the end of the travel range on the stanchion much higher up on the chassis of the fork, which again allows for more bushing overlap in the lowers. As I mentioned earlier, Fox said that the dual crown 40 has about the same amount of bushing overlap as the single crown Podium, which means it has about 45% more overlap than a 38:

 

The different crown shape and resulting lower crown "stack height" is the main reason why dual crown forks tend to have lower axle-to-crown heights than comparable travel single crown forks. For instance, a 180mm travel Manitou Dorado has a 582mm A2C height, compared to a 180mm travel RS Zeb with a much taller 596mm A2C.

Interestingly, it also results in a stiffer lower crown and arch shape, because both parts don't have to be as arched as they are on a single crown. For instance, look at the height of the arch on that 2025 Fox 40 versus a 36 from the same year. Smaller arch height = stiffer arch.

2025 Fox 36 FLOAT 29 Factory Grip X2 – Flow Suspension

 

It was interesting to work through this logic because it means that the design factors that make a RSU dual crown stiffer than a RSU single crown actually compound on each other: two crowns are obviously stiffer than one, but they also mean you can use a lower profile design on the lower crown (which is also stiffer), and this allows a lower profile arch shape (which is stiffer), and those two factors together allow you to sneak a longer overall stanchion length in the lowers and thus create more bushing overlap (which is even stiffer still). Dual crown forks also usually have bolt-on 20mm axles vs. the single-bolt 15mm axle you find on most RSU single crowns, and you end up with a drastically stiffer product.

6
1 hour ago

MTB forks are up against it as well vs. moto forks. 

Typical moto forks have one set of bushings affixed to the end of the inner stanchion. They ride in polished ways inside the outer stanchion. The outer stanchion have bushings pressed into them that ride on the inner stanchion.  During compression the bushings move away from each other increasing bushing overlap. 

2

Post a reply to: Suspension Component Technology/Functionality Discussion

The Latest