Pedal axle & crank spindle wear

AndehM
Posts
916
Joined
5/7/2018
Location
El Granada, CA, USA
Fantasy

I've noticed that on both my pedals (across a few sets) and a set of cranks that they develop a wear pattern on the underside (based on my typical descent position).  On one set of pedals (Deity Supervillains) the wear was bad enough that they developed enough play even after greasing that I had to replace the axles.  A second set of the same had marks but didn't have play after regreasing.  I replaced those pedals with RF Turbines, and after about 9 months, those developed a click that went away when I swapped bikes.  I haven't checked their internals, but swapping bikes would change their "down" position due to difference in crank arm threads.  When regreasing my BB (CK), I noticed the underside of my X0 crank spindle also has wear marks.  The bearings are all good across BB & pedals, and grease comes out clean, so I don't think it's contamination.  I don't wash my bikes with soap often (only a few times per year), usually just rinse with water once a week or so.

What could be causing this wear?  It seems excessive considering I only weigh 150 lbs and am not hitting pro-level jumps or anything, and only ride 3-4 days per week.  My best guess is the fine dust of my area sneaking past seals and slowly abrading the spindle/axle surface closest to the seals, but that doesn't explain why it's always on the bottom.

1
|
Primoz
Posts
4788
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
1 hour ago

The wear spot on the pedals (on the sliding bushings) should be on top. 

It's fairly normal as that's where the load is applied. 

With the BB axle it's probably moving around a bit, bending and deflecting, so it gets worn out slightly and isn't as tightly fitting as a new one. Aluminium is soft after all. 

AndehM
Posts
916
Joined
5/7/2018
Location
El Granada, CA, USA
Fantasy
36 minutes ago
Primoz wrote:
The wear spot on the pedals (on the sliding bushings) should be on top. It's fairly normal as that's where the load is applied. With the BB axle...

The wear spot on the pedals (on the sliding bushings) should be on top. 

It's fairly normal as that's where the load is applied. 

With the BB axle it's probably moving around a bit, bending and deflecting, so it gets worn out slightly and isn't as tightly fitting as a new one. Aluminium is soft after all. 

I get what you're saying, but the pedal axles are chromoly not aluminum.  Yeah it's possible to bend them, but it takes a pretty good crash (BTDT).  I've thought about it in the time since my post, and what I've come up with is that the Deity & X0 crank axles are anodized where the bushing/seals make contact.  Most other pedals that I have used (all in recent memory), have the whole axle anodized then the contact points for bushings/bearings/seals machined to tight tolerance.  So in the Deity/X0 case, the bushing/seal is rubbing against softer anodizing material, not hard chromoly.  And once the anodizing wears a little bit, the tolerance opens up for more wear to happen.

Primoz
Posts
4788
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
SI
3 minutes ago

Okay, a few things.

When I say bending, it's elastic bending. EVERYTHING bends. I'm not saying it was permanently deformed.
The thing is, even if anodized, it's still aluminium underneath. My DUB axles always showed signs of wear where the bearings are after a few seasons of use. And if there are wear marks, it got worn off a bit. Maybe just enough for it to be able to move around and creak. On another note, I saw a case where a shop somehow installed the cranks without the blue O-rings in the cups and that made the BB creak like crazy.

When you say Deity and mentioned anodizing, I think it's just black steel, probably from the heat treatment process and anything that is shiny is ground off. And if it's steel, it's the bushing that's getting worn. And buhsings getting worn and getting play is the reason why they don't work for suspension pivots even though bushings are TECHNICALLY superior for oscillating movements.

The solution? Honestly... Shimano cranks (steel spindle) or check the facing and/or interface for the BB bearings in case of DUB (is it possible the BB cups are somehow deforming too?) and pedals that use bearings instead of bushings or at least brass bushings instead of plastic. Or regular bushing changes...

Post a reply to: Pedal axle & crank spindle wear

The Latest