..not another MTB flat pedal shoe debate!!!

parnifel
Posts
103
Joined
10/15/2012
Location
CH
Edited Date/Time 10/27/2021 1:30am
Hey Vital readers
Hayden here...I thought I'd share my insights on a pair of flat pedals shoes I've been running for the last 6 - 6.5 months.
I am an experienced rider and ride 5-6 times a week. I am 5.7" and weigh 160 pounds, bike is currently a SC 5010 with a Cascade Link with 160 up front / 150mm out back / Pedals are the Burgtec MK4s.
I have tried a lot of different shoes in my 22 years of riding...until now the following shoes have been tried and trusted.
- Shimano AM4
- Giro Jacket
- Five Ten Freeride and Freeride Pro
- until recently the Five Ten Sleuth (this was my favourite shoe).

Just to make things clear, I am not an enduro racer, and none of this information is relevant, I just wanna share my positive experience.
I stumbled across the Vans Old School BMX and I must say - these are by far the best shoes I have ever tries and I will highly recommend them.
A lot of the forums (Reddit.com for example) also mention Vans Old School, but never the BMX versions of the shoe - we must agree that the tricks and things that BMXers are doing these days is mind boggeling...

The Vans BMX Shoes are comfy, grippy and have great cushioning...here are some pics of the shoes so far.
Feel free if you have any other ideas for good shoes.




|
Holeshot413
Posts
10
Joined
3/23/2021
Location
Big Bear City, CA US
10/24/2021 7:13pm
all I can say is since I switched to flats my knee pain has gone away!!
1
parnifel
Posts
103
Joined
10/15/2012
Location
CH
10/24/2021 9:33pm
Hey Holeshot413, thanks for the comment - I have a couple of friends who switched to flats due to knee pain.
10/25/2021 12:32pm
odd you guys have seen that result which would normally mean your Clip in setup was wrong as 99% of the time clip in is generally better for your knees as they have float that flats dont have.
Flats provide way more horizontal pivot grip than clips(because of float) and that leads to knee issues, i swap back an forth between flats and clips and i get odd knee feelings in flats (kinda like it needs to "click" mid way through a ride)
1
parnifel
Posts
103
Joined
10/15/2012
Location
CH
10/26/2021 4:49am
..just for reference sake: this thread was just to justify that the Vans BMX shoes that I've been riding have been holding up well and might be a option for some flat pedals riders.
I pretty much think the the whole Flats vs Clicks discussions have been covered (numerous of times)...
4
10/26/2021 7:47am
parnifel wrote:
..just for reference sake: this thread was just to justify that the Vans BMX shoes that I've been riding have been holding up well and might...
..just for reference sake: this thread was just to justify that the Vans BMX shoes that I've been riding have been holding up well and might be a option for some flat pedals riders.
I pretty much think the the whole Flats vs Clicks discussions have been covered (numerous of times)...
Wait, can you remind us why clips are better than flats? ;-P
4
10/27/2021 12:47am
the vans BMX shoes aren't bad at all! the compound is for sure grippier than the pro skate alternatives. I found the sole wore quicker though and at the end of the day with how often a good pro skate version is on roughly 50 percent discount i felt a bit stung for the price I paid and the wear life. this is not on mtb, just street BMX riding. I'm trying etnies semenuk pro next, they look really good and not that much more expensive than vans
parnifel
Posts
103
Joined
10/15/2012
Location
CH
10/27/2021 1:11am
Thats a good point - I sometimes think in some you have to decide what factors are important for a bike shoe, flat or clips.
I always though that the other brands were good (not saying that Vams are the best here)..but either you sacrifice grip for breathabilty / or looks for durability.
Its really like buying a bike, light and expensive or heavy and cheap > pick two!!
I ride alot, roughly 6 days a week and the Vans are looking good and my feedback is positive > always have been a Vans fanboy
Like the saying goes - different strokes for different folks.
parnifel
Posts
103
Joined
10/15/2012
Location
CH
10/27/2021 1:30am
@ FlatLander: I never said that flats were better than clips...I just want to share my experience with the Vans BMX Shoe
1

Post a reply to: ..not another MTB flat pedal shoe debate!!!

The Latest