The Good: Have been running it for about 3 years on a dirt jump bike. Comfortable to sit on but can't say how it would be on a long AM ride. It still looks almost new and i have the white version. Has survived some crashes at Rays indoor park without any issues.
The Bad: Only thing I can think of is rails are painted and are a little chipped around seat clamp. Very minor cosmetic issue only.
Strong solid seat. I would recommend it to a friend.